The Journal Says Trump Ordered the Strikes; CNN and ABC Say They Can Still Be Called Off
Three American outlets described the same decision on Iran within hours of each other on Friday, and each described it differently. All three rest on unnamed US officials.
The Wall Street Journal, relayed by Bloomberg and the Japan Times, reported that President Trump has ordered the US military to carry out a new attack on Iran as soon as this weekend, with the strikes intended to push Tehran to surrender. CNN’s live blog, updated at 1:10 AM EDT on Saturday, put it differently: the United States is planning fresh strikes as soon as this weekend, according to two US officials familiar with the plans, and CNN added that “the precise scope of the strikes and potential targets were not clear, and officials also cautioned the strikes could be called off.” ABC News, citing two US officials, reported that Trump is weighing a round of intense strikes and that planning is “well underway” but could change. Asked by reporters what Tehran can expect over the next four weeks, Trump said the United States would be hitting Iran “hard,” per Al Jazeera’s live blog of 31 July.
The target sets reported do not match. CNN said the military has made preparations for strikes on Iranian nuclear infrastructure including Pickaxe Mountain, south of Tehran, though not limited to that site, with preparations gaining momentum in recent days. ABC reported energy targets. ABC also reported that CENTCOM had previously prepared plans for a two-week air campaign, while some officials — one source only — believe a shorter, more severe salvo would better serve negotiations. ABC said potential strikes were discussed with Israeli officials; CNN said there is no indication Israel would take part. Israeli Defence Minister Israel Katz, quoted by CNN, said: “We very much want to strike Iran’s energy targets — the US is not approving it at this time.”
Assessment: The gap between “ordered” and “could be called off” is not a reporting failure, it is a bargaining position. Whoever briefed the harder version has an interest in Tehran reading the weekend as fixed, and there is precedent for the reverse: Axios reported on 25 July that Trump ordered the military not to strike, hours after an Omani delegation reached Tehran. Read the target discrepancy as the tell. Nuclear infrastructure and energy infrastructure are different wars with different oil prices attached, and Katz’s complaint that Washington is withholding approval on energy suggests the choice was still open when the briefings went out.