Likud loses the Knesset speakership 66 to 52, and the agenda with it
Matan Kahana of Gadi Eisenkot’s Yashar party was elected Speaker of the 26th Knesset on Tuesday, taking a bloc of 48 seats and turning it into 66 votes. A day later Haaretz reported Netanyahu was looking for a portfolio for the man he replaced.
The Knesset elected Matan Kahana, who ran fifth on Yashar’s list, as Speaker on Tuesday 17 November, replacing Likud’s Amir Ohana. Kahana drew 66 votes; Likud’s coalition whip Ofir Katz drew 52. The two were voted on separately rather than head-to-head, per CNN, so the figures are two ballots and not a single division. JTA reports Kahana was carried by the 48 members of Eisenkot’s four-party bloc — Yashar, B’Yachad, Yisrael Beyteinu and the Democrats — plus others; the 18-vote gap between the bloc and the count is the arithmetic that matters, and the exact breakdown has not been confirmed by the Knesset spokesperson. AsiaNews, single-sourced, reports roughly six hours of filibustering by Likud-bloc MKs beforehand. Eisenkot called the result a “proper democratic move which reflects the absolute majority who voted for change,” via UPI.
The speakership is not a ceremonial consolation. JTA frames the chair as the gatekeeping position for Eisenkot’s stated priority, a state commission of inquiry into the 7 October 2023 attacks; Times of Israel ran an 18 November analysis by Amanda Borschel-Dan and David Horovitz on the same premise, that control of the gavel is control of the order paper. The context is a coalition that does not yet exist. After the 27 October election, parties representing 67 MKs recommended Eisenkot to President Herzog against 46 for Netanyahu, and Herzog, quoted by Haaretz, said “the results of the consultations appear clear” while noting his duty to judge who can actually form a government. Netanyahu remains caretaker prime minister. On Wednesday, Haaretz reported — alone, and framed as “considering” — that he was weighing appointing Ohana strategic affairs minister despite legal advice against ministerial appointments during a caretaker period.
Assessment: Read the two days together. The side with the numbers took the institution that sets the agenda; the side without them began distributing compensation it may not legally be able to distribute. The Haaretz appointment story is single-sourced and unconfirmed by Likud, and should be held at that distance — but if the attorney general’s objection is ever put in writing, it stops being a story about consolation and becomes a justiciable act. The real test of Tuesday’s result is narrower than the commentary suggests: a date on the order paper for the 7 October commission. Until then, 66 votes is a majority assembled for one ballot, not a government.