Trump says he may designate the Brotherhood and names CAIR, but announces no instrument
The president told a reporter he “would, I might” issue a blanket designation and said Egypt had acted “at my request.” No legal tool, date or target list accompanied the remarks.
Speaking at the White House on Monday 16 November before departing for the Philippines and China, President Donald Trump was asked by Sarah Roderick-Fitch of The Center Square whether his administration would issue a blanket terrorist designation of the Muslim Brotherhood, and whether the Council on American-Islamic Relations could follow. “I would, I might. Egypt has clamped down on the Muslim Brotherhood at my request,” he said. Of CAIR: “another one that we are watching right now.” Asked directly whether CAIR could be designated, he said: “Well, I’m not going to say that yet, but it could happen.” And: “I think they’re both very dangerous. I think right now the Muslim Brotherhood might be more dangerous. It seems to be more in vogue.” The Center Square is a right-leaning outlet and its reporter framed the question by citing Egypt’s new steps; the quotes are on camera and syndicated across the Lee Enterprises network. Rio Times notes that no legal tool, date or target list was announced.
Two days earlier, on Saturday 14 November, Massad Boulos, Senior Advisor to the President for Arab and African Affairs, posted on X commending Cairo. Egypt Today and Ahram Online both carried the line: “The United States commends Egypt for permanently designating the Muslim Brotherhood a terrorist entity.” Around 13 November Trump told Hugh Hewitt that the Brotherhood was more dangerous than communists and called for it to be “neutralised,” The National reported; the same report notes the White House’s 2026 counter-terrorism strategy called the group the “root of all modern Islamist terrorism.” What exists in law is narrower. Executive Order 14362, signed 24 November 2025 and published in the Federal Register of 28 November 2025 at page 55033, invokes the Immigration and Nationality Act and IEEPA to start a process rather than to designate. On 13 January 2026 State and Treasury designated three chapters: the Lebanese branch, al-Jamaa al-Islamiyah, as both FTO and SDGT, and the Egyptian and Jordanian branches as SDGTs.
CAIR, the largest Muslim civil liberties organisation in the United States, publicly rejected the suggestion on 17 November, saying the White House should be addressing violence against American Muslims rather than attacking its rights work, and calling the suggestion a smear. The group is already classified as a terrorist organisation by Texas and Florida and is challenging both. The Intercept reported on 18 November that Governor Greg Abbott’s proclamation classified CAIR, its Texas chapter and the Brotherhood as foreign terrorist organisations and barred designated groups from buying land in Texas, and that the state’s incoming attorney general, Hinojosa, has promised to walk it back — a commitment The Intercept alone reports and which no statement from the office has yet confirmed. CAIR called the proclamation a “baseless, unconstitutional order.” The ACLU and CAIR have sued Governor Ron DeSantis over Florida’s designation on free speech and due process grounds.
Assessment: Read the “at my request” clause carefully. Egypt’s action was a prosecutorial step executing a Court of Cassation ruling, and no Egyptian source endorses the claim of American authorship; running the two together converts a presidential boast into a fact. The remarks themselves are the policy for now — ambiguity delivers much of the chilling effect of a designation while incurring none of the litigation exposure a published instrument would. The state-level track shows the limit. “When you get the right person in power,” the lawyer Imran Ghani told The Intercept, “it’s like — poof, the designation is gone almost overnight.” Designations that turn on an officeholder are rented, not owned.