COGAT says Rafah is open to people and closed to goods, and dates its numbers twice
An Israeli military body told the partisan outlet JNS on 18 November that about 7,500 Gazans have left for medical treatment through Rafah. Three days earlier it attached the identical figure to a different time period.
COGAT, the Israeli military body that administers civil affairs in the Palestinian territories, told JNS on Wednesday 18 November that the Rafah Crossing between Gaza and Egypt is open for limited travel but is not used to transfer goods. It said more than 52,000 Gaza residents had been evacuated from the Strip since the start of the war on 7 October 2023, of whom about 7,500 left through Rafah for medical treatment and about 7,300 have returned by the same route. JNS itself flagged the problem: in a post on X on Monday, COGAT said both Rafah figures covered the period since the ceasefire began on 10 October 2025, while Wednesday’s response gave the same numbers without specifying the period. COGAT said medical evacuations are coordinated with Egypt, the World Health Organization and the European Union Border Assistance Mission, and that the crossing reopened to limited two-way travel on 2 February.
Assessment: These are claims by an interested party relayed through a partisan outlet, not independently confirmed counts, and the date-range slippage is the reason to say so plainly. Identical totals cannot describe both a three-year war and a thirteen-month ceasefire; one of the two framings is wrong, and the difference changes what the figures mean about the pace of medical evacuation. EUBAM Rafah and the WHO hold independent tallies and have not published them this week. Egypt’s own figures for Rafah movements were not located at all — a gap worth noting, given Cairo’s interest in being seen to press for goods access. The one firm statement is the negative one: on 18 November, still no commercial cargo.