Paxton drops the Texas case against CAIR as Florida’s designation stays in force
The Texas attorney general’s office filed a notice of nonsuit in Collin County, abandoning the February suit that sought to shut CAIR and the Muslim Brotherhood out of the state. The claims can be refiled.
On or about 16 November, Attorney General Ken Paxton’s office filed a notice of nonsuit without prejudice in Collin County district court, dropping all claims in the lawsuit it brought in February 2026 alleging that the Council on American-Islamic Relations is the American extension of the Muslim Brotherhood and seeking to stop both operating in Texas. CAIR’s Dallas–Fort Worth chapter was among the named defendants. The notice, as reported by The Center Square via Yahoo News and KLIF and separately by The Gateway Pundit, states no reason. “Without prejudice” is the operative term: this is a withdrawal, not a dismissal on the merits, and not an exoneration. The Center Square copy says only that the office withdrew its claims before the incoming attorney general takes office; Gateway Pundit reads the timing as a response to Democratic midterm victories. No statement from Paxton’s office explaining the timing was located. The political-motive reading is inference, not reporting.
The state-level thread it belongs to is still moving in the other direction. In Florida, a new law took effect and Governor Ron DeSantis announced designations of antifa, the Muslim Brotherhood and CAIR; the governor and Cabinet approved the action on 29 October, and the CAIR designation took effect on 5 November after a court ruling, with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement as implementing agency. The state’s allegation of CAIR links to Hamas and the Brotherhood is a litigating position, not an adjudicated finding. South Shore Press, a partisan outlet reporting an unnamed newspaper’s interview, says Texas governor-elect Hinojosa will rescind Abbott’s 2025 CAIR proclamation, which CAIR is contesting in court; no direct quote and no confirmation from her office was available. Through all of it, there is no federal US terrorist designation of CAIR.
Assessment: A nonsuit without prejudice is the cheapest possible retreat: it preserves the theory of the case while conceding the calendar. Whoever inherits the Texas file inherits an open option, not a loss, and the absence of any explanation is consistent with an office that does not want the withdrawal read as a judgment about the merits. The more durable fact is the one the Texas and Florida actions both depend on and neither supplies — Washington has designated three Brotherhood chapters abroad and nothing domestically. Until that gap closes, state designations remain state-sized: enforceable by state agencies, vulnerable to the next election and the next court.