Israel publishes Rafah traveller figures that Egypt, which runs the other side, has not
COGAT told JNS the crossing is open for limited travel but moves no goods. No Egyptian, EU or Palestinian tally has been published to check it against.
In a written response to JNS on Wednesday 18 November, Israel’s Coordinator of Government Activities in the Territories said the Rafah crossing is open for limited travel but is not used to transfer goods, and described movement through the terminal as taking place “under a limited and supervised framework,” with Israel coordinating departures from and returns to Gaza. COGAT gave JNS three figures: more than 52,000 Gaza residents evacuated from the Strip since 7 October 2023, of whom about 7,500 left through Rafah for medical treatment, and about 7,300 who returned to Gaza through the terminal. The same account supplies a chronology — the crossing reopened to limited two-way travel on 2 February 2026 under the Gaza peace plan, attributed to the European Union; closed on 28 February when Israel and the United States struck Iran, which COGAT attributed at the time to the missile threat; and reopened in both directions on 19 March in coordination with Egypt.
Every one of those numbers is COGAT’s own, published by a partisan outlet and syndicated onward by Cleveland Jewish News. No corresponding Egyptian, Palestinian, EU or WHO count surfaced. JNS attributes the claim that the March reopening followed pressure from the Trump administration to the Israeli outlet Ynet — second-hand, single-outlet. On the Egyptian side of the ledger there is nothing: no MENA or State Information Service statement on Rafah throughput in November was recovered, and EUBAM Rafah, which the 2 February reopening was credited to, has published no traveller tally that could be set against COGAT’s.
Assessment: The absence is the story. Cairo has spent two years insisting the crossing’s closure is Israel’s doing, and it has built a mediation role on that claim — most recently the 13 November trilateral of Egyptian, Turkish and Qatari intelligence chiefs, which called for an immediate halt to Israeli violations. Yet Egypt operates one half of Rafah and publishes no figures, leaving an Israeli military body to define, unchallenged, what the crossing is and is not doing. Until Cairo contests “not used to transfer goods” with its own numbers, the only public record of Rafah is written by the party Egypt blames for closing it.