Trump floats a blanket Brotherhood listing as two US states pull CAIR opposite ways
The President said a wider designation “could happen” and that Washington is “watching” CAIR. No legal vehicle has been named, and none obviously exists.
Leaving the White House for Asia on 16 November, President Donald Trump told reporters he might extend the US terrorist designation to the Muslim Brotherhood as a whole, beyond the chapters already listed. The renderings diverge: The National Pulse headlined the remark “I would. I might.”; Rio Times reported he said a wider designation “could happen”; Al Jazeera quoted him on the Council on American-Islamic Relations saying, “CAIR is another one we are watching.” Muslim Mirror attributed the exchange to an interview with The Center Square, APA to a White House question-and-answer before the trip. All four are secondary outlets with evident and opposing leans, and this desk has not seen the pool transcript. Rio Times was explicit that nothing was announced: no instrument, no date, no target list. The National Pulse records that the reporter’s question opened by citing Egypt’s new measures.
What exists today is narrower than the rhetoric. Executive Order 14362, signed 24 November 2025 and published in the Federal Register on 28 November, says in its own text that it “sets in motion a process by which certain chapters or other subdivisions of the Muslim Brotherhood shall be considered for designation” — a process, not a designation. On 13 January 2026 the State Department designated the Lebanese Muslim Brotherhood as a Foreign Terrorist Organization and Specially Designated Global Terrorist, along with its secretary general Muhammad Fawzi Taqqosh; the Treasury designated the Egyptian and Jordanian branches as SDGTs for material support to Hamas, without FTO status. “These designations reflect the opening actions of an ongoing, sustained effort,” Secretary of State Marco Rubio said that day. FTO designation under 8 U.S.C. 1189 requires a defined foreign organisation. A transnational movement with no single legal personality does not obviously supply one.
CAIR, which has never been designated by the federal government, replied through a statement to Al Jazeera on 17 November, attributed to the organisation rather than a named officer: “The Trump administration should focus on addressing this surge in violent hate, not entertaining smears against the civil rights organisation that counters such hate.” The states are moving in both directions at once. On 4–5 November Chief US District Judge Allen Winsor, in the Northern District of Florida, declined to block Florida’s domestic terrorist designation of CAIR, granting relief only as to the provision of legal services; CAIR-Florida suspended operations on 5 November. Attorney General James Uthmeier called it a “great win”; ACLU senior counsel Ashley Gorski said an appeal is planned. On 15 November, Texas Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa told The Washington Post she will revoke Greg Abbott’s designation of the same organisation.
Assessment: The instrument is the story, and there isn’t one. Everything the administration has actually done — the executive order, the January listings — ran through statutes that require a named foreign entity with a chain of command. Applying that to a movement defined by affinity rather than incorporation is a legal problem no official has yet addressed on the record, and the absence of an answer is more informative than the remark. Meanwhile the real pressure on CAIR is subnational: a Florida designation that closed a chapter without any federal finding, and a Texas reversal promised by someone not yet in office. Treat EgyptToday’s 14 November report that Massad Boulos praised Cairo’s permanent listing as an Egyptian account of a US position until a US release carries it; no such release surfaced.